CDFL asked: 10/14/2013
A man has a mental breakdown. During this, he murders someone. Should he be punished for his actions? (Assume with certainty this breakdown was a random one-time occurrence, and he had no real control over what he was doing)
Punishment No Punishment
Punishment No Punishment
large pie chart
Punishment No Punishment
75% 25%
58 Votes
75% 25%
Gender
MF
75% 33 small pie chart
75% 24 small pie chart
Age
<2121-40>40 0%78%68%
0% 0 small pie chart
78% 41 small pie chart
68% 16 small pie chart
Income
<50k50-100k>100k 70%86%66%
70% 17 small pie chart
86% 23 small pie chart
66% 12 small pie chart
Party
DemocratRepublicanIndependentLibertarian 73%75%80%0%
73% 15 small pie chart
75% 8 small pie chart
80% 25 small pie chart
0% 3 small pie chart
Alaska (0 votes)
100%
Alaska
(0 votes)		 100%
Alabama
(1 votes)		 100%
Arkansas
(1 votes)		 100%
Arizona
(0 votes)		 100%
California
(7 votes)		 42% 58%
Colorado
(3 votes)		 66% 34%
Connecticut
(4 votes)		 75% 25%
Wash. D.C.
(1 votes)		 100%
Delaware
(0 votes)		 100%
Florida
(5 votes)		 80% 20%
Georgia
(1 votes)		 100%
Guam
(0 votes)		 100%
Hawaii
(0 votes)		 100%
Iowa
(0 votes)		 100%
Idaho
(1 votes)		 100%
Illinois
(3 votes)		 100%
Indiana
(1 votes)		 100%
Kansas
(0 votes)		 100%
Kentucky
(1 votes)		 100%
Louisiana
(0 votes)		 100%
Mass.
(2 votes)		 100%
Maryland
(0 votes)		 100%
Maine
(0 votes)		 100%
Michigan
(2 votes)		 100%
Minnesota
(1 votes)		 100%
Missouri
(1 votes)		 100%
Mississippi
(0 votes)		 100%
Montana
(0 votes)		 100%
N. Carolina
(2 votes)		 50% 50%
N. Dakota
(0 votes)		 100%
Nebraska
(0 votes)		 100%
N. Hampshire
(0 votes)		 100%
New Jersey
(2 votes)		 100%
New Mexico
(0 votes)		 100%
Nevada
(0 votes)		 100%
New York
(3 votes)		 66% 34%
Ohio
(1 votes)		 100%
Oklahoma
(0 votes)		 100%
Oregon
(3 votes)		 100%
Penn.
(2 votes)		 100%
Puerto Rico
(0 votes)		 100%
R. Island
(0 votes)		 100%
S. Carolina
(0 votes)		 100%
South Dakota
(0 votes)		 100%
Tennessee
(0 votes)		 100%
Texas
(3 votes)		 100%
Utah
(0 votes)		 100%
Virginia
(1 votes)		 100%
Virgin Is.
(0 votes)		 100%
Vermont
(0 votes)		 100%
Washington
(5 votes)		 60% 40%
Wisconsin
(1 votes)		 100%
W. Virginia
(0 votes)		 100%
Wyoming
(0 votes)		 100%
Last updated: 2024-04-19T22:31:53+00:00